When reading for B370 this weekend, I came across this paragraph in my textbook. It was discussing culture and cohesiveness of a group, and how it can vary over cultures. Being the culture fanatic I am, I was completely looking forward to this section of the book and the information I could get from it. Here is the paragraph I came across:
“ How concerned group members are about hurting group cohesiveness by engaging in heated debates-and the effects of such debates on group performance-may also vary across culture. Roger Nibler and Karen Harris (2003) studied five-person groups of strangers and friends in China and the United States. The groups’ task was to rank 15 items to be taken aboard a lifeboat from a ship that was about to sink. This task tends to trigger a fair amount of initial disagreement among group members until a consensus can be reached. With the Chinese groups and the groups of American strangers, these kinds of disagreements tended to be perceived as troubling and interfered with group performance. To the groups of American friends, in contrast, these disagreements were more likely to be seen as simply part of a freewheeling debate, and the sense of freedom to exchange opinions and disagree with one another tended to improve performance on this task.”
What is this? This doesn’t explain anything….yeah, I would have guessed that to be the outcome as well…I understand that for purposes of this textbook a full research study isn’t plausible to be written in, but could they at least print the full results. This doesn’t help in a cultural form in anyway…this could be placed in the area that isn’t emphasized in cultural terms. The results even say ,in contrast to,….in contrast to what? You didn’t even talk about the Chinese results…there isn’t even a comparison to make….
This is an issue that plagues American psychology….we don’t have the ability to mass produce cultural implications into anything… This is why students don’t have a global perspective on things, because even when a textbook claims to be “culturally aware” it isn’t…we only care about our own results of studies…and then play it off as though we are being culturally relevant….it’s not…
Saturday, January 22, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)